Surveillance & Spyware

Surveillance by governments and companies, including spyware and face and licence plate recognition, and the rulings and investigations around it.

Webloc, Penlink's ad-based location surveillance system, and its customers in more countries

According to Citizen Lab's update of 12 November relaying a Bloomberg investigation, security agencies in more countries, including the UK, Germany and Singapore, have acquired Webloc, which tracks phone locations using app and advertising data. The confirmed customers in Citizen Lab's April report were in the United States, El Salvador and Hungary, and the update adds that Austria's Ministry of the Interior has been confirmed as a customer (checked on 14 November). Phone settings for tracking and location permissions can reduce what apps send out, but the report says they cannot reliably prevent it.

Based on 6 sources, including Citizen Lab, National People's Congress, e-Gov 法令検索

The Ninth Circuit appeal over a cell tower dump warrant

The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit is hearing an appeal over a tower dump warrant, which demands location data for every phone in a given place at a given time from mobile carriers. EFF and the ACLU argue that these warrants are unconstitutional in themselves. As of 8 November we could not find a government brief in the appeal, and our inference is that turning off Google Location History does not stop a tower dump.

Based on 13 sources, including EFF, The Register, SCOTUSblog

Facial recognition and mall cameras in Hong Kong's SmartView programme

According to Hong Kong media reports of a police briefing on 5 November, facial recognition is due to be added to the SmartView programme within November, and cameras at the first malls could be connected by the end of the year. The police said the connection complies with Hong Kong's privacy law, but as of 8 November we could find no public response from the Office of the Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data, and neither facial recognition nor the mall connection had been announced as launched. People who live in Hong Kong or travel there for leisure or business may have their images sent into the police system when they pass through a connected mall, and places outside Hong Kong are not affected.

Based on 19 sources, including Hong Kong Police Force, Hong Kong Free Press, 星島頭條

Cross-border trade in surveillance technology and export controls

An October commentary on Global Voices maps the trade in surveillance technology such as facial recognition and deep packet inspection among Russia, China, Iran, Venezuela and Belarus. International rules on exporting such technology are mostly voluntary or left to each state to enforce. Japan, South Korea and India are Wassenaar participants; mainland China and Taiwan are not. We checked the reports the commentary cites and found several claims worded more broadly than their sources.

Based on 32 sources, including Global Voices Advox, Forbidden Stories, Federal Register

Disputed matching of protest footage by Baden-Württemberg police and Berlin's behaviour-recognition cameras

According to court testimony reported by netzpolitik.org, an officer at the State Criminal Police Office of Baden-Württemberg in Germany ran footage of a registered demonstration through a computer after the event and identified four participants who, to date, have no connection to the case. In October, Berlin police began testing cameras that analyse behaviour at high-crime locations, and the police law rules out automated facial recognition on that footage. The EU AI Act in principle prohibits real-time identification by law enforcement in publicly accessible spaces, while post-event identification is classed as high-risk and becomes subject to authorisation and other rules from December 2027.

Based on 32 sources, including netzpolitik.org, Polizei Berlin, Gesetz- und Verordnungsblatt für Berlin

Lawsuit and criminal investigations over Telenor's Myanmar user data

Telenor's Myanmar subsidiary handed user data to the military after the 2021 coup, and its Norwegian parent now faces a class action, which a court allowed to proceed on 17 September. Norwegian police have also opened two criminal investigations into the parent company. According to Telenor, local law required it to provide the data, and employees who refused risked imprisonment, torture or the death penalty. The case also raises how user data and surveillance equipment are handled when a telecom operator leaves a country.

Based on 23 sources, including Open Society Justice Initiative, SOMO, Politiet

CCTV at Hong Kong malls and the police SmartView programme

Hong Kong's Secretary for Security said in an interview on 18 October that some CCTV cameras at private shopping malls will be connected to the police SmartView programme, with talks in their final stage. He also said the public may not need to be told separately, and in February said that third-party connections are one-way and that footage on the government system is generally kept for 31 days. People travelling to Hong Kong for leisure or business may be caught on camera in public areas of malls, and places outside Hong Kong are not affected. According to Hong Kong media reports, facial recognition is being piloted in parts of the system.

Based on 23 sources, including Security Bureau, Hong Kong Police Force, Hong Kong Police Force, Legislative Council Secretariat

Zero-click spyware delivered through targeted ads

Citizen Lab published a report on 15 October linking, with high confidence, attacks on at least 45 Al Jazeera devices between 2024 and 2025 to targeted ads from the Israeli ad firm Discover-Tech and spyware from Candiru. Al Jazeera is the only confirmed target, and the exploited vulnerabilities are not described. The advice for general readers is to block ads and limit advertising IDs, which according to the report lowers only part of the risk.

Based on 18 sources, including Citizen Lab, IAB Europe, Adtimizer

Surveillance technologies in migration and border control

Privacy International published a guide in September to 12 categories of technology used by immigration and border authorities, including phone extraction, drones, GPS tagging and algorithmic decision-making. Migrants and asylum seekers are directly affected, and the fingerprint and face checks travellers meet at borders fall into one category. Public documents from UK, German, Canadian and EU bodies set out their purposes and safeguards.

Based on 12 sources, including Privacy International, Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge, Frontex

US Police License Plate Readers and a Florida Arrest

Flock's license plate reader cameras, used by US police, saw a run of developments in August and September. Flock shortened its default data retention, a Senate subcommittee held a hearing, and Florida and Texas restricted the cameras. A woman who was arrested and then not prosecuted sued two state troopers. The practices are confined to the US, and readers elsewhere are not directly affected.

Based on 14 sources, including Florida Department of Transportation, National Sheriffs' Association, Flock Safety

The UK Supreme Court ruling on state immunity in a spyware claim

The UK Supreme Court ruled that Bahrain cannot claim state immunity to stop a UK court hearing claims that it hacked computers in the UK with spyware operated from abroad. The ruling decides only whether UK courts can hear the case, and whether the hacking happened has not been tried.

Based on 10 sources, including UK Supreme Court, legislation.gov.uk, Citizen Lab

Recognising and responding to Apple threat notifications

Apple sent mercenary spyware threat notifications to users in 110 countries in August, though the vast majority of people will never be targeted. Apple's support page lists where genuine notifications appear and what they never ask for, and recipients can turn on Lockdown Mode and seek help.

Based on 11 sources, including Apple, Freedom of the Press Foundation, TechCrunch

ZuckOff, a Bluetooth detector for camera smart glasses

ZuckOff matches Bluetooth broadcasts to warn that camera glasses such as Ray-Ban Meta are nearby. It cannot tell whether anyone is recording, and the app itself is closed source.

Based on 7 sources, including ZuckOff, App Store, WIRED Middle East